Nova Jersey, 1992. Quando o corpo mutilado de mais um homem rico e secretamente homossexual aparece, o Projeto Antiviolência de Nova York (AVP) pressiona a polícia a investigar um serial killer que tem como alvo homens gays.
A break in forensic technology leads investigators to a suspect: a nurse living on Staten Island. The next step is to decipher his past—a quest that takes them back almost 30 years to a murder in Maine—and to make sure he doesnt evade justice.